1991-1992 – Jason Casessa, Hoboken
1992-1993 – Alex Rodriguez, Secaucus
1993-1994 – Eduardo Gomez, Hoboken
1994-1995 – Cheri Selby, St. Dominic Academy
1995-1996 – Rashard Casey, Hoboken
1996-1997 – Czar Wiley, North Bergen
1997-1998 – Koz Perez, North Bergen
1998-1999 – Mike Forcum, Hoboken
1999-2000 – Jonathan Robinson, Memorial
2000-2001 – Tiffany Aciz, Secaucus
2001-2002 – Bryan Durango, Memorial